Your manager asks you to drop a signed contract at a client’s office across town. You say yes, grab your keys and head out in your own car. Nothing goes wrong, and that is the end of the story. But what if something did go wrong? Say you rear-end another car at a red light on the way back. Who pays: you, your employer, or both of your insurers?
Plenty of people assume the company has them covered because they were doing a work task. That assumption is common, and it is only partly right. What protects you depends on which policy a claim lands on first and what that policy really promises. Here is how it usually works in the United States.
Your own policy usually pays first
When you drive your own car, your personal auto policy is normally the first line of protection, even if you were on a work errand. Insurance follows the vehicle, and the vehicle is yours. Industry sources describe the employee’s personal policy as primary, which simply means it pays first, up to its limits.
Here is the catch. Many personal policies contain a business-use or commercial-use exclusion. If your insurer decides the trip counted as business driving, it may argue that the exclusion applies and deny the claim. Whether that happens depends on your policy wording, how often you drive for work and your state. We explain the difference between commuting and work driving in our guide to business use car insurance. It is much better to ask your insurer before an accident than after one.
What your employer’s coverage is really for
Many companies carry a coverage called non-owned auto liability, often sold together with hired auto coverage. It applies when an employee drives a vehicle the company does not own, such as a personal car, on company business. The important word in that sentence is “company”. This coverage exists to protect the business from being sued. It is not built to protect you as the driver.
It also tends to be narrower than people expect:
- It usually pays second. It generally responds in excess of your personal limits, meaning after your own policy has paid what it can.
- It does not fix your car. Damage to your own vehicle is normally handled by your collision coverage and your deductible.
- It does not cover your injuries. If you are hurt while driving for work, that is usually a workers’ compensation question, not an auto liability claim. The details vary by state.
- It may not exist at all. A small employer with no company vehicles may never have bought it.
Commuting is a different story
Driving from home to your regular workplace and back is generally treated as commuting, not as work. If you crash on your commute, the employer is usually not responsible and your personal policy deals with it. The picture changes when the driving itself is part of the job: visiting clients, moving between sites, collecting supplies or making deliveries. That is the situation this article is about.
A simple example
The numbers below are made up, but the pattern is realistic. Priya sells dental supplies and drives her own car to visit clinics. One afternoon she causes a crash, and the other driver’s car and medical bills come to $90,000. Her personal liability limit is $50,000. Her insurer pays up to that limit, if it accepts the claim. The remaining $40,000 is the gap.
If her employer has non-owned auto liability, that policy may respond to the gap, mainly to protect the company. If the employer has no such coverage, the other driver can still go after the company, because Priya was working, and after Priya personally. Either way, her own car’s repair bill comes out of her collision coverage. Low personal limits are exactly where this kind of story gets painful.
Questions to ask your employer
- Does the company carry non-owned auto liability, and does it cover employees who use their own cars?
- Do I need to keep a minimum amount of liability coverage on my personal policy to drive for work?
- How often am I expected to drive for work, and will that change?
- What is the reporting process if I have an accident during a work trip?
- Will the company reimburse any extra premium if my insurer charges more for business use?
Try to get answers in an email or a signed policy rather than a hallway chat. If something goes wrong, a written record helps everyone.
Questions to ask your insurer
- Does my policy exclude driving for work, and does my kind of driving count?
- Can I add a business-use endorsement, and what would it cost?
- What are my liability limits, and are they enough if I cause a serious crash?
- Would an umbrella policy add useful protection?
Be honest about how you use the car. Telling an insurer the car is for personal use only, when it is not, can cause real trouble at claim time or at renewal.
Mileage pay is not insurance
Some employers pay a set rate per mile for work trips. That money covers fuel and wear on the car. It does nothing if you cause a crash. Reimbursement and insurance are separate things, and one does not replace the other.
When it is more than an occasional errand
Occasional errands are one thing. If your job means you are on the road most days, you may need a different setup. A business-owned car usually needs commercial auto insurance. Driving for an app is its own category, so read about rideshare insurance and delivery driver insurance rather than relying on a general add-on. If you mostly work from home and only drive out now and then, our page on work from home car insurance explains how insurers see limited driving.
The takeaway
If you drive your own car for work, assume your personal policy comes first, and assume your employer’s coverage, if it exists, is there mainly for the company. Check your policy for a business-use exclusion, ask your employer what it carries and make sure your liability limits are high enough that a bad day does not become a financial disaster. If your current insurer cannot or will not cover the way you drive, you can compare quotes in minutes and tell each company exactly how you use the car. Our guide on how to compare car insurance quotes shows how to keep that comparison fair.
Coverage rules and exclusions vary by insurer, employer and state. Read your own policy and ask for answers in writing.
Sources
- CEPro: should employees use personal vehicles for work?
- TotalCSR: non-owned auto coverage explained
- The Horton Group: are employees driving their own vehicles a business risk?
- Progressive Commercial: employers non-owned auto coverage
Enter your ZIP code to see options that fit your budget. It is free and only takes a few minutes.
Your ZIP code is only used to show quotes available in your area.
This article is for general information only and is not insurance, legal or financial advice. Coverage, rules and prices vary by insurer and state.