Pay-Per-Mile Car Insurance: Is It Right For You?

If you work from home, live in a city or just do not drive much, you may feel like you are paying for miles you never drive. Traditional car insurance is priced partly on estimated annual mileage, so a lighter driver can end up with a similar price to a heavy one. Pay-per-mile insurance tries to fix that.

The idea is simple, but it is not for everyone. Here is how it works and how to tell if it fits you.

How Does Pay-Per-Mile Insurance Work?

Your price has two parts. First, there is a base rate, a fixed monthly amount. Second, there is a per-mile rate, a small charge for each mile you drive. Add them together and you get your monthly bill.

As an example, one insurer’s public sample showed a $29 monthly base rate plus six cents a mile. If you drove 600 miles that month, the bill would be $29 plus $36, so $65. Real rates differ by insurer, state and driver, so treat that only as an illustration.

Get a free quote

Get Free Insurance

Quote online Now!

Quick
Easy
No Obligation

Compare quotes and see how much you could save.

Your privacy and security are important.

Who Might Benefit

Remote workers
No daily commute can mean far fewer miles.
Retirees
Many drive occasionally for errands and visits.
City dwellers
Public transport and walking mean the car sits more.
Second-car owners
A spare vehicle that rarely moves.

How Do You Know If You Drive Little?

State Farm’s consumer guide notes that the Federal Highway Administration puts the average at just over 11,400 miles a year. Many pay-per-mile guides suggest it tends to suit drivers well below that, often under about 10,000 miles a year. Check your own odometer readings over a few months before deciding.

How Is Mileage Tracked?

Methods vary. Some insurers use a small device plugged into the car, some use a smartphone app, some use connected-car data and some ask for odometer photos. Think about how comfortable you are with that kind of tracking and what data is collected.

Possible Downsides

Availability is limited, and only some insurers offer true pay-per-mile plans in some states.
Heavy drivers can end up paying more than with a standard policy.
Your bill changes month to month, which can be harder to budget for.
Tracking involves sharing some driving data.

A Simple Way To Compare

Estimate your yearly miles. Ask for a pay-per-mile quote and a standard quote with a low-mileage discount. Work out the yearly total for each at your likely mileage and add some extra for busier months. If the pay-per-mile total is clearly lower, it may be worth trying.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the coverage the same as a regular policy?

Generally the coverage types are similar. What changes is how the price is calculated. Always check the coverage limits.

Are there other ways to save if I drive little?

Yes. Many insurers offer a low-mileage discount, and some offer usage-based programs that look at driving habits. See our guide to auto insurance discounts.